2026 Best Catholic Colleges in New York

Name: 2026 Best Catholic Colleges in New York (Kollegio college rankings)
Creator: Kollegio
License: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

15 New York schools ranked in Kollegio's 2026 Best Catholic Colleges ranking, based on U.S. Department of Education College Scorecard data.

Showing 1–15 of 15 colleges · How we rank colleges

Filter by

Cost of attendance after aid

ⓘ

$77,180

Institution type

2 Year4 Year5 Year

Field of study

Sort By

Campus Detail

Institution setting

AllCitySuburbanRural

Undergraduate enrollment

ⓘ

268763

Financial

Alumni starting salary

Tuition cost

ⓘ

$67,000

In-state tuition

ⓘ

Proportion of need based aid received

ⓘ

100%Clear Filter

International students received aid

ⓘ

100%

Average aid package

ⓘ

$82,308

Application fee

ⓘ

$150

Academics

Mean GPA

ⓘ

Mean SAT

ⓘ

1200

Mean ACT

ⓘ

#1 Best Catholic Colleges

Fordham University

Bronx

Acceptance rate

56.3%

Institution type

UNIV

Total Tuition Cost

$54,730

Avg. Cost after Aid

$38,000

#2 Best Catholic Colleges

Siena College

Loudonville

Acceptance rate

77.6%

Institution type

COMP

Total Tuition Cost

$39,925

Avg. Cost after Aid

$33,000

#3 Best Catholic Colleges

Le Moyne College

Syracuse

Acceptance rate

75.3%

Institution type

4YEAR

Total Tuition Cost

$35,610

Avg. Cost after Aid

$25,000

#4 Best Catholic Colleges

Molloy University

Rockville Centre

Acceptance rate

75.6%

Institution type

UNIV

Total Tuition Cost

$32,900

Avg. Cost after Aid

$26,000

#5 Best Catholic Colleges

Canisius University

Buffalo

Acceptance rate

81.8%

Institution type

4YEAR

Total Tuition Cost

$29,300

Avg. Cost after Aid

$18,000

#6 Best Catholic Colleges

St. John Fisher University

Rochester

Acceptance rate

67.8%

Institution type

UNIV

Total Tuition Cost

$35,352

Avg. Cost after Aid

$27,000

#7 Best Catholic Colleges

Manhattan University

Riverdale

Acceptance rate

78.5%

Institution type

COMP

Total Tuition Cost

$42,800

Avg. Cost after Aid

$28,000

#8 Best Catholic Colleges

Niagara University

Acceptance rate

85.3%

Institution type

COMP

Total Tuition Cost

$34,400

Avg. Cost after Aid

$18,000

#9 Best Catholic Colleges

St. John's College (IL)

Queens

Acceptance rate

83.4%

Institution type

UNIV

Total Tuition Cost

$43,962

Avg. Cost after Aid

$29,656

#10 Best Catholic Colleges

Iona University

New Rochelle

Acceptance rate

91.1%

Institution type

4YEAR

Total Tuition Cost

$40,628

Avg. Cost after Aid

$29,000

#11 Best Catholic Colleges

Mount Saint Mary College

Newburgh

Acceptance rate

82.5%

Institution type

4YEAR

Total Tuition Cost

$34,782

Avg. Cost after Aid

$23,000

#12 Best Catholic Colleges

St. Bonaventure University

St. Bonaventure

Acceptance rate

81.5%

Institution type

COMP

Total Tuition Cost

$36,520

Avg. Cost after Aid

$26,000

#13 Best Catholic Colleges

College of Mount St. Vincent

Riverdale

Acceptance rate

84.6%

Institution type

COMP

Total Tuition Cost

$39,500

Avg. Cost after Aid

$20,000

#14 Best Catholic Colleges

Hilbert College

Hamburg

Acceptance rate

98.0%

Institution type

COMP

Total Tuition Cost

$24,435

Avg. Cost after Aid

$17,000

#15 Best Catholic Colleges

Villa Maria College

Buffalo

Acceptance rate

86.7%

Institution type

4YEAR

Total Tuition Cost

$24,700

Avg. Cost after Aid

$15,000

2026 Best Catholic Colleges in New York

Best Catholic Colleges in nearby states

More college rankings in New York

Browse more